Extreme Terrain
4x4Wire Trail Talk Forums: Jeep, Toyota, Mitsubishi, Pajero, Isuzu, Kia, 4WD, 4x4, SUV, Off-Road and OutdoorWire Forums


Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
Trail Rated B.S. #352050 11/23/03 05:59 PM
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 57
JOEDIRT Offline OP
Getting the Wheeling Fever
What is this shi+ in jeep comercials about being trail rated. This will make me just want to run out and buy one. Right. I think Zoo should bring back the VX or Sport. Both of these would whoop that liberty.


97 TJ SE, intake, baja wheels, 31" mudders
Stripped down to a rollin gas can.
Re: Trail Rated B.S. [Re: JOEDIRT] #352051 11/23/03 06:48 PM
Anonymous
Unregistered
I believe one of the standards, or marketing ploys if you like, is that every Jeep model must be capable of navigating the Rubicon one way or another. About 6 months ago I read an article in an industry magazine that there are those within Jeep who want to drop this standard, as it adds cost and time to the development process. Their argument being that the average owner does not need that level of off-road readiness and a new cheaper and less capable model would help increase profits.

Re: Trail Rated B.S. #352052 11/23/03 07:25 PM
Anonymous
Unregistered
Quote
every Jeep model must be capable of navigating the Rubicon one way or another.


ok.........NO!
that's a negatory, there's no way a liberty or a grand cherokee (maybe a rubicon wrangler) could navigate the rubicon without a crane goin w/ the jeep stackin rocks
why you ask? those suspensions suck coil sprung but still they suck, my friend's got a grand and it doesn't flex for anything, no flex, no ground clearance, there's really nothing that seperates them from the rest of the crowd, aside from the rubicon comin w/ lockers and goodyear mtr's, there's nothing really all that special about 'em, i know my friend w/ his grand always says to me "i dunno if my jeep can make it through this man, we should prolly take your trooper" i love that too, i love being told by a jeep owner, that your sleeper trooper is better suited than my supposed rubicon ready jeep!

Re: Trail Rated B.S. #352053 11/23/03 09:34 PM
Joined: Nov 2000
Posts: 663
LTC Don Offline
Rock Warrior
Quote
i know my friend w/ his grand always says to me "i dunno if my jeep can make it through this man, we should prolly take your trooper"


Now that would make an awesome commercial <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/kewl.gif" alt="" />

Cheers,
[Linked Image]


Don B.
1991 Trooper LS 2.8L V6 with some stuff
Johnston County Industries
PlanetIsuzoo Discussion Forums
Re: Trail Rated B.S. #352054 11/23/03 10:11 PM
Anonymous
Unregistered
Quote
First released for sale in the U.S. in Spring 2001, the Jeep Liberty is set to capture new market share for Daimler-Chrysler. It's turned out to be one of those vehicles you either love or hate. People love the Liberty (or Libby as some call it) for it's comfortable ride, yet tough ancestry. The majority of those who dislike the Liberty seem to be owners of pre-IFS (independent front suspension) Jeeps. The Liberty has drawn some fire for the controversial decision made by Daimler-Chrysler to convert to IFS since this type of suspension is often seen as weeker than a live axle setup. DC, however, maintains that the Jeep Liberty is just as tough as all the other Jeep models and took a Liberty over the Rubicon Trail as proof (all Jeep models released to date have been taken over the Rubicon in stock shape prior to being labelled a Jeep).


That was taken from here
And this from Car and Driver.
Quote
In other words, Jeep solemnly swears its newcomer has mastered the Rubicon and survived the same military-spec 15,000-mile off-road duty cycle to which all Jeeps are subjected.

With a little carnage from fourwheeler.com
Quote
Out on the Rubicon the Liberty works well enough, though not as well as it would work with a rear locker and serious off-pavement tires. Lots of grinding, however, was heard from meetings of Rubicon rock and Liberty engine/trans/T-case skidplates. In one case the skidplate and transmission pan were so seriously mashed as to shut down the transmission. This caused trailside repairs and some heavy thinking by the engineers. Interestingly, we found that LibertyÆs plastic fender flares fold completely up when brushed against obstacles, then pop right back into shape. WeÆve learned the hard way that the same obstacles peel the flares off a Cherokee


There is a bit of controversy over the Rubicon. Some feel that the modern crop of wheelers have had a negative impact, changing the trail as it has become too "easy" for the huge rubber and massive articulation that is the trend today.
As far as Jeep is concerned I have no idea what lines they took or obstacles they bypassed, but as far as getting it from point A to point B using the trail I believe it's possible. I started wheeling about ten years ago in a 1978 Subaru Brat and went all kinds of places I was told I could never make it, with one stuck and zero breakage. With a good driver and "creative" lines almost any trail is possible.
There is a lot of Jeep bashing in this forum and I don't get it. My family has owned several models and all have been awesome as commuters and off-road. They are a bit boring and "cliche" but IMO that doesn't make them bad vehicles. And for your friends G.C. not being able to follow your Trooper, how can I be delicate, he must be new to wheeling. Not saying it's better, but given equal drivers (you may be super talented for all I know) you guys ought to have no trouble playing on the same trails. I had a friend, some years back who bought a ready made wheeler ( lifted bronco, 35's etc...) and used to leave it behind on tougher sections to ride in my near stock 87 cherokee. I got tired of teasing him and coerced him into driving an obstacle in the Bronc I had no hope of making in my SUV. When he made it the first time with not even so much as a spun wheel the light went on, and the look on his face was priceless.
I didn't mean for this to take on a "Jeep's are great" flavor, I meant to re-enforce that the driver is much more important. Any decent SUV or pick-up can be navigated through things many would deem immpossible. Given the opprtunity I would have jacked/stacked and pulled my old GEO Tracker though the Rubicon. Here's a good Illustration of what I'm talking about. The white Pathfinder (stock, LSD) is me making the top of the hill after everyone else gave up and was ready to leave after many attempts. It took a good 30 min for me to get it but I wasn't backing down... literally.
[img] [image]http://www.angelfire.com/extreme/hawaiianhardbody/images/FFD/28.JPG[/img] [/image]
and some of the guys who couldn't make it
[Linked Image]
[Linked Image]
Apologies for no good pics of the overall obstacle.

Re: Trail Rated B.S. #352055 11/23/03 10:34 PM
Anonymous
Unregistered
here is what is disappointing about jeeps in general:

Isuzu doesn't market its trucks as "THE vehicle to have off road"

Jeep does.

Jeep TELLS PEOPLE in no uncertain terms "if you are going off road, you need a jeep"

but when I look at just about any stock jeep I see worthless toy skidplates (if it even HAS them to begin with) worthless ground clearance, worthless wheel wells that require huge lift for any kind of respectable tires.

This is not to say that jeeps are garbage, in fact my girlfriend has an XJ that I recommended and picked out with her -

I'm just saying that IF jeep is going to say their trucks are built for trail use THEN they need to build them for trail use. with real skidplates, metal bumpers, and wheel wells that will be friendly to some owners' tire choices. You know, like my 1991 trooper came with stock.

It wouldn't hurt if they threw in rocker panel guards too, or built the vehicle with bomb proof rocker panels because you know that's the first thing to get trashed on a low 4x4.

As for this "rubicon rating" hype, I don't really care if they actually "rate" their stuff or not but I call bulls#!% on how they rate it. I would be willing to bet I could drive any family sedan through the rubicon eventually, if it was ok to trash it and repair it on the trail.
Harold Pietschmann took a mercedes minivan on the rubicon, even - just to prove that it could be done.

http://4x4abc.com/ML320/ML320_RUBICON2.html

If they're going to say "can do the rubicon", it needs to be able to be driven right off the showroom floor by an average novice driver and then run the rubicon with no heroic effort by the driver, and no damage whatsoever to the vehicle.

Edit: as for the IFS on the liberty, I see it as just fine. I know of a certain other kind of vehicle that has IFS and seems to do pretty well off road <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/kewl.gif" alt="" /> <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/kewl.gif" alt="" />

Re: Trail Rated B.S. #352056 11/23/03 11:07 PM
Anonymous
Unregistered
Quote
And for your friends G.C. not being able to follow your Trooper, how can I be delicate, he must be new to wheeling. Not saying it's better, but given equal drivers (you may be super talented for all I know) you guys ought to have no trouble playing on the same trails.

well, he's not the greatest of drivers, but nobody's as good as they'd like to be, but, how can i be delicate, sorry, when it comes to having to cross a trail that requires a respectable amount of ground clearance, suspension travel and beefy skidplates to travers, his gc falls short of my trooper, both have skids, coil sprung rear (you'd think he'd have the advantage w/ the solid coil front but it just doesn't flex very well, i've tried to get it to flex, but jeep doesn't give enourmous amounts of flexin room) and four wheel drive, however, my more generous ground clearance (especially now) and more willing-to-flex-to-maintain-traction suspension, and more abundant and beefy skids all allow me to traverse a trail that the grand would have to have extra vehicular assistance to traverse, i like the vehicle, very supple on road ride, and it maintains smoothness off road, however it has developed some discouraging rattles over time, more than one would expect, nice stereo, good luxrious interior, decent 4 litre i-6. overall a great vehicle, for a daily driver, i'd prolly take it over my troop, b/c of its amenities, however, considering i'm very fond of hoppin curbs in the middle of traffic to find a "short cut" i'll hold on to my troop, and after my lift and new tires (which would require more funds to do the same to his grand, b/c of tiny wheel wells and what not) he's really been lookin at my troop w/ a lustfull twinkle in his eyes

Re: Trail Rated B.S. [Re: JOEDIRT] #352057 11/24/03 12:04 AM
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 9,030
randii Offline
4x4Wire.com Managing Editor Emeritus
Jeep does a GREAT job of marketing. I wish Isuzu would follow suit -- bone-stock, I'd take a 3.2 V6 Isuzu Amigo over a Jeep TJ with the 4.0 inline 6. Jeep raised the stakes with the lockered and low-geared Rubicon TJ and Isuzu changed the Amigo to a Rodeo Sport... then discontinued it. <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/rolleyes.gif" alt="" /> A true shame, since had Isuzu followed suit and marketed and delivered an Amigo/Rodeo Sport with Tera lows and Air Lockers at both ends, they'd have had a vehicle that IMHO would sell like *mad*.

All speculation, though -- shame we'll never know. <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/frown.gif" alt="" />

In the meantime, I'll not beat Jeep up for marketing their vehicles well (they sure do!) and testing every vehicle on the Rubicon (seen it with my own two eyes). The folks to gripe about IMHO is the folks who spout the resulting market-ese as drivel (though it is certainly fun to strap those folks outta the mud with anythyng-but-a-Jeep), and the folks at Isuzu who are unwilling (or perhaps un-funded) in the fight to compete with Daimler-Chrysler-AMC-Willys-Ford and their marketing efforts.

Just a reminder, though -- vehicle-bashing (ANY marque) isn't really welcome here. We're here to talk Isuzus, right? <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/kewl.gif" alt="" />

Randii


Randy Burleson
4x4Wire Managing Editor Emeritus
Mongrel Isuzu Amigo
Re: Trail Rated B.S. [Re: randii] #352058 11/24/03 01:20 AM
Anonymous
Unregistered
We all like to bash jeeps but they really are the most capable vehicle in stock form. As far as the GC is concerned, but pardon me for calling BS. Either he can not drive or you have one badass Trooper. I had a 97 with coil spacers and ran 31's and that was a great machine with a ton of flex. Most jeep guys will tell you that the GC is right behind the TJ capability wise in stock form. I like to hate on jeepers as much as the next guy, but lets face, you can go buy an 04 GC, try to buy an 04 Trooper. Marketing works.

Re: Trail Rated B.S. #352059 11/24/03 02:32 AM
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 9,030
randii Offline
4x4Wire.com Managing Editor Emeritus
Quote
We all like to bash jeeps but they really are the most capable vehicle in stock form.

Disagree -- on both points! I don't like to bash Jeeps(tm) or jeeps (general 4x4s), though I do enjoy teasing Jeepers(tm) who discount my jeepin' (general 'wheeling)... and unless you place a load of qualifiers on that 'most capable' comment, I won't agree there, either. <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/pfft.gif" alt="" /> Certainly some Jeeps are capable trail-runners in box-stock condition, but that can be said of other marques, as well!

Quote
...but lets face, you can go buy an 04 GC, try to buy an 04 Trooper. Marketing works.

I won't argue with you that the various owners of the Jeep marque have done an OUTSTANDING job of marketing their brand, but that's a whole different discussion, IMHO, from capability.

Randii


Randy Burleson
4x4Wire Managing Editor Emeritus
Mongrel Isuzu Amigo
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3







4x4Wire Social:

| 4x4Wire on FaceBook |


OutdoorWire, 4x4Wire, JeepWire, TrailTalk, MUIRNet-News, and 4x4Voice are all trademarks and publications of OutdoorWire, Inc. and MUIRNet Consulting.
Copyright (c) 1999-2019 OutdoorWire, Inc and MUIRNet Consulting - All Rights Reserved, no part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without express written permission
You may link freely to this site, but no further use is allowed without the express written permission of the owner of this material.
All corporate trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3
(Release build 20190728)
PHP: 7.4.33 Page Time: 0.009s Queries: 16 (0.007s) Memory: 0.6434 MB (Peak: 0.7750 MB) Data Comp: Off Server Time: 2026-11-16 08:32:36 UTC
Valid HTML 5 and Valid CSS