ONEOFAKIND
... but I wanted to pull the plug wires 1 at a time to see if I could hear a diffence but... they all sounded the same. Even if all the cyl. are ok there still should have been a difference when I disconnected the plugs unless this is what is happening right? ...
mlclark
It only works if you are trying to find an IGNITION based problem.
Time to get out the compression gauge.
well, a different point of view:
in my experience with other engines, the pull-the-ignition-wire-off-the-plug cheap-man's diagnostic aide, works irrespective if the problem is IGNITION related or not.
what you are testing here, or rather looking for, is an indication that a cylinder is or is not contributing it's equal share. if it is not, that will show up as no, or little, decrease in rpm when that plug wire is disconnected.
it really doesn't matter *why*, just *if*, as far as this diagnostic test is concerned.so in my opinion,
ONEOFAKIND , your original bafflement was valid. ""Even if all the cyl. are ok there still should have been a difference..."" if all was well, then each plug wire pulled should show an equal drop in rpm; if one cylinder had problems (for whatever reason), then the rpm drop would have been less or negligible because that cylinder was not fully contributing its fair share, and so it didn't have its full complement of "contributing rpm" to begin with.
i am interested in why you didn't experience *any* drop from *any* cylinders. could it be the mlclark factor? :-)
as to whether the computer masks small rpm drops, i don't *know*, but it sounds logical.
anyway, that's my take. . .
all this being said, the compression test (and a leak-down test) will of course give you more definitive data as to valves, rings, etc. whether you do the ignition wire routine or not.
//bc