USAA for military only, otherwise Amica. They run 1-2 year after year in customer satisfaction. Geico bought radar and laser guns for the cops so they could raise rates when you got ticketed. Don't bend over around State Farm or Allstate, or the good neighbor or good hands will eff you over. Nationwide is on your side, your back, and around your neck.

I also had decent luck with Liberty Mutual.

Not responsible for advice not taken...