I am not sure the nada and kbb links will provide much info to help.

Basically, you have a (basic) 20 year old vehicle that was never a big seller. The auto is desirable. Should be an AW-15 (maybe 5, never could keep the numbers straight). However, good auto tranny. Downside is IFS and oversize body.

If it were a solid axle Toyota, you would have more bargain power.

Personally, you have an extra zero in your price range. Brother picked up a low miles (50+k) 86 Toyota with a V-6 transplant (Jeep odd-fire) with straight axle for $800.

You have a good vehicle. But, it does not have the desired components to command top dollar.