Locker...but...
Unfortunately, most people don't know about the hazards of winching until it is too late (present company excluded)...nor do they know about proper care and feeding of a winch. A poorly maintained winch used improperly is like pointing a loaded gun at yourself and pulling the trigger.
I have several winches, and here's what I would suggest:
1. If you buy used, send it to get a CERTIFIED clean bill of health from one of the winch manufacturer's authorized service centers. This includes solenoids (if electric) and cable (unless you are using RockStomper Rope) or buy a new cable that has been certified by the manufacturer as being free of defects at the rated load for the winch and have the service center spool it onto your drum under load.
2. Winch mounting instructions come with fastener torque specifications. Use them. Once a year. Paint mark your bolts across one flat and the mounting point. Inspect the paint marks BEFORE going out on the trail EACH TIME and retorque any fasteners that have moved.
3. Diesel fuel is your friend. Unspool your cable into an oil drain pan (the kind that holds 3 gallons and has a drain spout)and fill the pan with diesel until the cable is fully submerged. Leave it this way for 24 hours, then drain off the excess diesel. Wait another 24 hours and drain off the diesel again, then install your cable. Do this once a year.
4. Properly installed and stretched winch cable will lay flat on the ground when you pull it out. Cable that has not been stretched will coil up into a hairy mess. a 100' 5/16 wire rope can stretch eight feet under tension.
Stretch your cable by spooling out all except five turns and attaching to an anchor point. Back your vehicle away until the cable is under tension, set your parking brake, and leave your truck that way for 24 hours. Come back, tighten the cable by either backing up or spooling onto the drum, leave it another 24 hours. Repeat one more time for a total of three (3) days, then spool it on. It will lay flat when unspooled.
5. Buy a Danforth anchor rated for the same load as your winch. You may get out there and have nothing to which you can anchor...and it beats burying the spare.
6. Buy a "recovery kit"...consists of a snatch block, a tree strap (which is different than a recovery strap), two
(2) "D" shackles, a towing chain, and leather gloves.
So...to sum up...buy a locker and a recovery strap UNLESS you are willing to make the full committment (proper winch, proper training and technique, proper maintenance, healthy battery/charging system (if electric), etc.
There's nothing worse than a cable breaking or a planetary set fragging right in the middle of a recovery. Property gets damaged and people get injured...or killed.
Rob in Hell