Your starter will handle starting in gear just fine- in low range it works great. Do it all the time.

Sounds like your solenoid contacts are worn. $12 from the dealer. The FSM details much (but not all) of the disassembly; removal is the hardest part. Roger has information on his site:
http://www.4crawler.com/4x4/CheapTricks/Starter.shtml

I had my starter and our 2WD starter go on the fritz in one day. $12 fixed them both, I used one contact per.


-Bill
'87 4Runner w/ '96 5VZ-FE, 'Red Chili II'
'97 Taco XtraCab 3RZ-FE, 'BlackBean'
TLCA # 13257, Rising Sun 4x4 Club Land Use Coordinator
"He who stops being better stops being good." -Oliver Cromwell