Butt-welding is a reasonable way of repairing steel rod, but just isn't the best* way to deal with axles that handle rotational torque. Axles use specialized metallurgy and depend on consistency in grain, profile, and heat treatment along the length of the axle to spread the load. Any spikes or differences interfere with distribution of the load. Even if you could get both pieces fixtured perfectly in the same axis, and then welded without heat-shifting that axis, the resulting axle would be uneven, and thus weak.

* In certain cases, butt-welding axle shafts is reasonable due to the production tolerances, subsequent processing/treatment OR inaccessibility for repair.

IMHO, changing the length of a vehicle shaft is not a good application for butt-welding.

Randii


Randy Burleson
4x4Wire Managing Editor Emeritus
Mongrel Isuzu Amigo