I just talked to CV Unlimited about replacing my broken Newfield axle. In case anyone else deals with them, definitely always work through George. He seems like the only one there that actually knows their Toyota products and replacement policy. I'll get one free replacement and 50% off the following one. But it would have been like pulling teeth to get any replacement if George wouldn't be there.
I found Steve Hunt's broken axle pic again. His failed in a perpendicular line that sheared across the axle at the same general location as mine did. From a web search on metallurgy, I just learned that that's called a brittle failure. Mine is split at 45 degrees for about a 2" length, which is more of a ductile failure. So this is the first time that I actually have any evidence that CV Unlimited really did do heat treating of the outer joint and axle to make it flex more to withstand shock loads. Ductile failure good. Brittle failure bad.
One interesting point is that the ADD outermost axle shaft is thicker in that location since it's also under constant tension and helps hold the hub together so the wheel doesn't fall off. I had noticed this and wondered if ADD axles are stronger because of that - depending on where's the weakest point along the half-shaft. George mentioned that there isn't much they can do to improve the strength of the outer axle where I broke it, so the ADD axle can be made stronger than the manual hub axle, as long as the CV joint is stronger than that section of axle. CV Unlimited does make Newfield axles for ADD 4Runners, if anyone's interested in that tidbit. But if you break an ADD outer axle shaft instead of the outer CV joint, you need to have a trail spare or you'll be hurtin'.
Jeff 2000 4Runner SR5, supercharger, rear e-locker, ARB front locker, 285/75R16 MT/R's, custom bumpers & skids 2007 Tacoma double cab 4x4 - stock
|