Extreme Terrain
4x4Wire Trail Talk Forums: Jeep, Toyota, Mitsubishi, Pajero, Isuzu, Kia, 4WD, 4x4, SUV, Off-Road and OutdoorWire Forums


Previous Thread
Next Thread
Print Thread
Rate Thread
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3
No Auto Insurance for Isuzu #652182 10/03/05 04:53 AM
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 81
E
EricW Offline OP
Getting the Wheeling Fever
I have had the same insurance company (Geico) for about 12 years with no problems with coverage or premiums. About every year to year and a half I will call around to check on better rates and have never had anyone to beat their premiums.
The other day I got a mailer from AIG Auto Insurance stating that they consitantly could beat Geico's rate by $331.20 a year so I gave them a call. I was asked to supply info on the autos in which I would like a quote on....
(phone conversation)
1989 Chevy... OK Sir next vehicle
2000 Dodge... OK Sir next vehicle
1996 Isuzu... -------------------
I was then told that AIG has a strict policy not insuring Isuzu Troppers, not only would they not insure an Isuzu, but would not even give me a basic quote on my other 2 autos. I asked they guy why not and he told me that once he entered into the system that I owned an Isuzu the system "Black Flags" my household. <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/zombie.gif" alt="" />
I have never had this happen before when calling around to check rates. Anyone out there been denied coverage due solely to owning an Isuzu?


1996 Trooper S 3.2 5sp OME919/ProComp ES9000
BFG Dueler A/T REVO 265/75R16 w/Snowflakes
1991 Trooper 2.6 5sp 33x12.5 BFG T/A
Re: No Auto Insurance [Re: EricW] #652183 10/03/05 05:03 AM
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 7,268
Happy Birthday mlclark Offline
Isuzu Moderator
*****
Yup, we are all driving around without insurance.

Frankly, a) you don't want a company that has policies like that and b) it is just a way of keeping their premiums down. If you only insure what you consider "safe" you don't have the cost of paying out as often. It is the same reason that it is a bit more difficult (and expensive) to get life insurance if you skydive.

Now, why is Isuzu not considered "safe"? I don't know.

Here is my rant: What exactly does my credit rating have to do with what they charge me for insurance? Apparently something. Some research, somewhere, connected credit rating with insurability. Never mind the fact that I have no claims on my insurance record, no tickets on my record and my credit rating is "clean" (i.e. no late payments, no unpaid anything) but instead my debt to income ratio is high (poor student, again). So, because enough people who were "high risk" also did not pay their CC bills, I get to pay more. <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/rolleyes.gif" alt="" />

Crooks? Yes.

Michael

Re: No Auto Insurance [Re: mlclark] #652184 10/03/05 05:12 AM
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 81
E
EricW Offline OP
Getting the Wheeling Fever
Quote
Frankly, a) you don't want a company that has policies like that and b) it is just a way of keeping their premiums down. If you only insure what you consider "safe" you don't have the cost of paying out as often. It is the same reason that it is a bit more difficult (and expensive) to get life insurance if you skydive

I guess that is why the say they can beat the rates of other companys, by selective underwriteing.
I asked the rep if it was just Isuzus' or other autos also.
He said that there were others but could not list them for me.


1996 Trooper S 3.2 5sp OME919/ProComp ES9000
BFG Dueler A/T REVO 265/75R16 w/Snowflakes
1991 Trooper 2.6 5sp 33x12.5 BFG T/A
Re: No Auto Insurance [Re: EricW] #652185 10/03/05 03:09 PM
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 2,652
W
Wayne Offline
Roll Me Over
Quote
It is the same reason that it is a bit more difficult (and expensive) to get life insurance if you skydive

I've never had a problem. Well, a mid-air parachute malfunction once, but I (obviously) lived, but what I mean is I've not had a problem with insurance. I made certain to even ask on my work policy to verify that "extreme recreational activities" were covered. Then I printed out the answers and stuck them in my "death folder."

Smaller policy writers are (I'm guessing) more likely to "cherry pick" the healthiest groups of people, but with smaller companies you have to worry about them having the money to pay out.

My real problem is the bulk of my insurance has to be through military sources as almost every other insurance policy out there has "war zone" clauses, where "war zones" are defined by how they don't want to pay. Front line? War zone. In the rear with the gear? War zone. American base in Germany? Terrorist target, war zone.

FWIW, y'all might want to check your personal policies--after 9/11, most put in Terrorism and many put in Mass casualty clauses. ("You're covered only if you die alone of natural causes--and no one finds the body, but there's conclusive evidence of death. Fine print: Eating fries even once is unnatural and disqualifies you in the event of a heart attack.")

Quote
Here is my rant: What exactly does my credit rating have to do with what they charge me for insurance?

It's sort of like zip code--how does your zip code affect how you drive (Price for personal liability coverage, not the comprehensive 'replace if stolen' cost which is more obviously tracked to where you park your car at night). Credit rating is for a group, and in those groups, certain average behaviors have been noted.

The official answer I see is that people with good credit are more responsible and better drivers, and people with bad credit are more likely to get in an accident. I believe (personal observation) that people with more credit are more likely to sue and cost the insurance company more money working the claim....or having to defend themselves when someone gets drunk, rolls their car, hurts them self, and thinks that it should be the equivalent of winning the lottery.

Here's a good explanation straight from the government

They should factor in student-ness in the debt ration when insuring your Isuzu, if they wanted to be fair. You wouldn't want to tick off a future doctor that incurs tons of debt, but buys expensive policies later.


[color:"white"]? 04 Rodeo DI ?[/color] 75k mi, body damage on the 1st weekend I got it.
Re: No Auto Insurance [Re: Wayne] #652186 10/03/05 04:14 PM
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 7,268
Happy Birthday mlclark Offline
Isuzu Moderator
*****
It's sort of like zip code--how does your zip code affect how you drive

It was a rhetorical question, Wayne. <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" /> Your zip code analogy makes sense, in that if you happen to live in an area that is crime-prone, then yes, it should cost you more. Don't like it? Move.

Credit worthy-ness, or even your use of the term "good" credit is bunk. All the sudden they are making a binary decision (good vs. bad) based on whatever calculation they come up with. I am sure this calculation is done in their favor. So, all the sudden, I am lumped in the category of people with unpaid bills, legal judgements, bankruptcies, and divorces. Why? Because their calculation also looks at things like debt:income or debt:total credit available. Part of that is student loans. Just wait until 4 years from now... While I do not have multi-decades of credit history, I do have a clean record that shows responsible management use of the credit I do have.

Gubmin't or private research aside, this ends up giving them a shortcut to stick it to certain groups. Income challenged, students, whoever. We all know research describes groups as a whole, not the individuals. In this case, I think (yes, my opinion) there is a vast number of individuals who are not represented by the group, but are included anyway. The standard deviation becomes large.

Just as above, this allows for insurance companies to make wide sweeping policies that drive their decision making. No Isuzus, higher rates for their self-defined "bad" credit customers, again, whatever they dream up. Apparently they give no weight to the accident-less record, claim-less record and the fact I have been with the company since I started my driving career. Well, occasionally they toss a "good driver" bonus in, but does it ever come close to the less than fair policies that drive the majority of their pricing scheme?

Michael (Isuzu-ness: Yes, my Isuzu is insured)

Re: No Auto Insurance [Re: mlclark] #652187 10/03/05 05:32 PM
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 2,652
W
Wayne Offline
Roll Me Over
I forgot, we didn't get a sample of your DNA yet.

I am distresed they would exclude an entire vehicle class (Isuzu or just the Trooper) That seems almost illegal; definitly worth reporting to the state insurance comission.


[color:"white"]? 04 Rodeo DI ?[/color] 75k mi, body damage on the 1st weekend I got it.
Re: No Auto Insurance [Re: EricW] #652188 10/03/05 05:47 PM
Joined: Aug 2002
Posts: 3,007
Richard Saylor Offline
Roll Me Over
*****
Quote
I asked the rep if it was just Isuzus' or other autos also. He said that there were others but could not list them for me.


That right there sounds like a load of bull to me. If you ask me, that's probably information that they would be required to give out upon request.

Richard <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/patriot.gif" alt="" />


Had an 89 Isuzu Pickup
Had a 94 Mitsubishi Eclipse
84 Honda XL185S
Had an 89 Isuzu Trooper w/ 3.4 V6
01 Toyota Tundra SR5 V8 4Door Access Cab
http://community.webshots.com/user/rsayloriii
Re: No Auto Insurance for Isuzu [Re: EricW] #652189 10/03/05 07:33 PM
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 1,873
H
holger Offline
Body Damage is Cool
Eric, the isurance company sounds like an unprofessional one. You should let the comany name to be known.

I hate to say this, but the 'group-policies' are very close to the racist behavior. If the racism is a bad thing (judging people on some unrelated group features, like skin color) and this is illegal, then why is this legal to judge people according to others group features (zip code, car make etc) ? Suppose, you are an Asian guy. If they would turn you down becouse of your skin color (some races have better driving average records, some have not so good records) you would sue them becouse if some others Asian guys drive stupid (suppose, statistics confirms this), it has nothing to do with your personally and you are not responsible for this. But when you are turned down becouse some others Trooper owners were in accidents, this must be illegal also ! And if your zip code neighbors do something wrong then again, it has nothing to do with you personally, and you must not be responsible for this !

I wonder how come in this sue-happy country nobody sued the insurance companies. This country needs more lawers <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />


Oleg
Axiom 4WD 2004: OME shocks, 32" BFG Mudders, RockSliderz, OME929+2" spacers, Stinkyfab bent RE rear links, front ARB locker, rear No-Slip locker, DOR front axle lowering kit, custom middle section skid plate, IronMan torsion bars.
Deceased Rodeo'02 4WD.
Re: No Auto Insurance for Isuzu [Re: holger] #652190 10/03/05 07:52 PM
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 9,030
randii Offline
4x4Wire.com Managing Editor Emeritus
Quote
I wonder how come in this sue-happy country nobody sued the insurance companies. This country needs more lawers <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" />

Because of very effective lobbying, it is VERY difficult to successfully sue an insurance company... you can sue the coverage, but the company assets themselves are incredibly well-protected, and in cases of massive payouts, are themselves insured (and in cases, backed up by pre-negotiated federal bail-outs, offered in case of disasters).

The layers to this issue are so many, that most folks just throw up their hands in disgust, understanding just a smidgen of how actuarial tables (credit, age, location, etc.) affect rates. That's before we even START to talk about re-insurance capacity, which underlies the standard actuarial tables and further drives prices.

For a case study, look to the event insurance policy for Moab 'Zu Zoo, where rates went up 33% for the second year, 100% more for the third year, and a staggering 300% more for the fourth year -- a total increase of 750% <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/angry.gif" alt="" /> over four years. You'd think that successive years would cost less due to experience, with no claims against the insurer... not 7.5 times more! FWIW, these rates were the best I could find at the time, after aggressively shopping around, and were driven in significant part but terrorist acts and natural disasters. I'm trying to secure coverage for Moab 'Zu Zoo IX prior to the next re-insurance renegotiation at the beginning of the year, because Katrina and Rita are gonna further hammer capacity and 'Zu Zoo, Inc. can't absorb that kind of hit again.

Damn frustrated about insurance in general,

Randii


Randy Burleson
4x4Wire Managing Editor Emeritus
Mongrel Isuzu Amigo
Re: No Auto Insurance for Isuzu [Re: randii] #652191 10/03/05 09:01 PM
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 2,652
W
Wayne Offline
Roll Me Over
Randii,

I can actually explain why the costs went up so much. 1/3 lawyers, 1/3 personal responsibilty, and 1/3 based off the waggling of the S&P 500, and fear of 1 lawsuit.

See the link here. It's long, but a very interesting read.
http://users4.ev1.net/%7Esanaghan/main/Outdoor_Rec/News-Outdoor.htm

This was somewhat (though not as much) as I'd like covered in various outdoor magazines, and I stole/consolidated from there. Of course the mainstream press barely touched on it. I took what I found, added, updated, re-wrote, better explained, and paraphrased parts to make this version. I think it's still majority from Outdoor or Sierra magazine text at this point.

Strange thing is there's no real conclusion. I searched and searched and it looks like the final lawsuit was settled with an agreement more or less down the middle. I should probably do another lexis-nexus search, unless someone else has a reliable source. Googling didn't do it.


[color:"white"]? 04 Rodeo DI ?[/color] 75k mi, body damage on the 1st weekend I got it.
Page 1 of 3 1 2 3







4x4Wire Social:

| 4x4Wire on FaceBook |


OutdoorWire, 4x4Wire, JeepWire, TrailTalk, MUIRNet-News, and 4x4Voice are all trademarks and publications of OutdoorWire, Inc. and MUIRNet Consulting.
Copyright (c) 1999-2019 OutdoorWire, Inc and MUIRNet Consulting - All Rights Reserved, no part of this publication may be reproduced in any form without express written permission
You may link freely to this site, but no further use is allowed without the express written permission of the owner of this material.
All corporate trademarks are the property of their respective owners.

Powered by UBB.threads™ PHP Forum Software 7.7.3
(Release build 20190728)
PHP: 7.4.33 Page Time: 9.313s Queries: 16 (0.011s) Memory: 0.6543 MB (Peak: 0.7842 MB) Data Comp: Off Server Time: 2026-11-18 11:52:22 UTC
Valid HTML 5 and Valid CSS