It's sort of like zip code--how does your zip code affect how you drive
It was a rhetorical question, Wayne. <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/smile.gif" alt="" /> Your zip code analogy makes sense, in that if you happen to live in an area that is crime-prone, then yes, it should cost you more. Don't like it? Move.
Credit worthy-ness, or even your use of the term "good" credit is bunk. All the sudden they are making a binary decision (good vs. bad) based on whatever calculation they come up with. I am sure this calculation is done in their favor. So, all the sudden, I am lumped in the category of people with unpaid bills, legal judgements, bankruptcies, and divorces. Why? Because their calculation also looks at things like debt:income or debt:total credit available. Part of that is student loans. Just wait until 4 years from now... While I do not have multi-decades of credit history, I do have a clean record that shows responsible management use of the credit I do have.
Gubmin't or private research aside, this ends up giving them a shortcut to stick it to certain groups. Income challenged, students, whoever. We all know research describes groups as a whole, not the individuals. In this case, I think (yes, my opinion) there is a vast number of individuals who are not represented by the group, but are included anyway. The standard deviation becomes large.
Just as above, this allows for insurance companies to make wide sweeping policies that drive their decision making. No Isuzus, higher rates for their self-defined "bad" credit customers, again, whatever they dream up. Apparently they give no weight to the accident-less record, claim-less record and the fact I have been with the company since I started my driving career. Well, occasionally they toss a "good driver" bonus in, but does it ever come close to the less than fair policies that drive the majority of their pricing scheme?
Michael (Isuzu-ness: Yes, my Isuzu is insured)