I had the Kayline/STS soft top and it's a great piece but I still don't think that one is worth the price. I prefer the Kayline/STS style over this hearse look and the material doesn't matter to me as much because it's going on a 17-21 year old vehicle. I made my own rail mounts like Roger had on his site and it worked great. I can't see paying more than $450 for any soft top since you will most likely remove it for the winter anyway. I left my soft top down almost the entire summer until we finally started to get some rain.