It really depends on the type of off roading. The long travel IFS is a great for anything that requires super good handling or good rebound suspension, such as sand dunes, jumping, high speed desert running, dirt roads, etc. It works OK for the rest of off roading, and less than OK for anything serious like rock crawling.
Long Travel IFS also has the disadvantage of limited aftermarket support for stronger axle and steering components, whereas the SAS stuff can be built to exceptionally strong levels, with beefy steering and super strong Longfield axles and birfs. You also have a bigger and stronger front diff to work with.
For most off roading and almost any kind of trail running, IÆd rather have the SAS for durability and for the articulation, which really does make a difference. A long A-arm IFS can be built with minmal lift, which does make for a more stable platform and the suspension does articulate very well compared to stock, but you still have the same disadvantage of lack of axle leverage.
If I spent more time on the highway, deserts, dunes, fire/logging roads, the long travel IFS is more enjoyable to drive and offers an exceptional ride and handling.
In the end, I would never buy anything from Downey. Especially something this expensive. They just do not have the experience in designing a good quality long travel IFS, whereas Total Chaos has been working on this system since the early 1990s. The biggest bugs were making the upper arms strong enough to support the weight without cracking. Particularly in the area where the torsion bars attach to the arms. Total Chaos uses better materials and better bracing, which ôshouldö solve those problems. The other issues involve strengthening the steering, which is pretty strong in stock form, except the idler arm, and how the axles are set up for the long travel.
Older kits used a very expensive system that used stock out CVs, custom axles and long travel Porsche style inner CVs that allowed the axles to slip in and out further and the suspension cycled. However, when parts broke, they were expensive to replace. Total Chaos was wise enough to design their kits to allow the use of stock T-100 half shafts, which are a dime a dozen. This limits the travel to less than what the custom axles could provide, but makes the set up much more cost effective.
Whatever you do, donÆt waste youÆre time with DowneyÆs long travel axles as they are not designed to be run at speed.
In the end, I think SAS is the better option for most off roaders. But long travel IFS does have advantages for very specialized types of off roading.