Sorry to hear about that. I got rear ended a few years ago by someone with Nationwide and got totally ripped. I had a 1974 Volvo 145 Wagon that I had invested about $6000 (in the previous 12 months) and Nationwide totaled it and offered me a check for $1800 even though I provided receipts. In the end I "paid" them a $300 salvage fee and kept the car and $1500 and got the requisite bodywork done for $1200.

1998 Mitusbishi Montero (winter package)
1987 Land Rover One Ten