Jim, dude, have you ever overtightened a pinion nut and smoked an axle?
I've certainly seen what happen when the under-qualified do jobs they should have let a pro do.
If it comes to being on the roads and highways with DIY's running questionably repaired rigs or rigs having been repaired properly/professionaly...If you feel there is a contest here... chime in. Otherwise read what is in front of you, this particular fellow clearly has no clue as to what to even call the part that is bad, much less install it correctly.
There are MANY qualified DIYers out there, I'm happy for them, that is how I got started in this industy.
Even today, I won't work on my diesel engine myself, because I'm underqualified to do it. I change the oil and use only oe parts.
SD
No I have not ever overtightned an axle nut..
I respect your oipnion Supe. However most folks that don't know what they are doing would find it hard to overtighten an axle nut without propper tools. Usually with meager tools it would he hard indeed to get 150lbs on that nut.
To me it is a simple matter of a $10 seal versus a $600 pro install of new bearings and a complete reseting of the R$P.
I have been riding for 2 years on a rear end that I replaced the seal on the pinion. In fact I drove it this morning in the rain.
Although WE here in the states depend on professional mechanics to do menial work...around the world replacing that seal is a common practice.. If all it needs is a seal... for gods sake just replace the seal.
Big Jim <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/pfft.gif" alt="" />