|
|
|
|
Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
#822578
07/02/07 05:11 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 262
OP
Mudrunner
|
Looks like O2 sensors for my car are about $50 to 75ea. I found generic ones for about half that price, $25, but it doesn't look like they come with the harness.
I dont mind cutting and slicing my old harnesses from the bad sensors, but will these generic sensors be any good???
1997 Isuzu Rodeo S 4WD
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: Tygger]
#822579
07/02/07 05:36 PM
|
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 416
Mudrunner
|
In my experience they are kind of hit and miss. I used them on my old mitsu p/u (only 1 wire) and one of them always read a little low. The one I replaced it with worked fine though.
--Dave
1999 Rodeo LS 3.2 4x4 5 Speed 32x11.50-15 BFG T/A KO on US Wheel 94 series 3" Lift - Rancho 9000x Rear No-Slip Locker Flowmaster 50 series SUV 2.25"
There is a very fine line between "hobby" and "mental illness." - Dave Barry
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: Gizzy42]
#822580
07/04/07 04:04 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2006
Posts: 362
Mudrunner
|
In my experience they are kind of hit and miss. I used them on my old mitsu p/u (only 1 wire) and one of them always read a little low. The one I replaced it with worked fine though. X2 Gizmo, Ive never had any luck with them either, Especially Bosch one's.
89'Isuzu Trooper LS 5 spd 2.6L 31" Big O X/T's 15x8 Eagle 058's K&N Filter w/ Air Box Mod 2.25" DynoMax SuperTurbo PolyUrathane/Indy4X Bushings Suspension/ FrontEnd Tech/Hunter Certified Alignment Tech.
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: 88SuperTrooper]
#822581
07/05/07 05:57 AM
|
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 416
Mudrunner
|
I put the Bosch o2 sensors with factory plugs in my rodeo a few months ago and they are working fine. My mileage went up a bit after replacing the originals that had 100k miles on them. I've never been a fan of Bosch but havent had problems with their stuff on the rodeo. The ones I had in the mitsu were some off brand I think.
--Dave
1999 Rodeo LS 3.2 4x4 5 Speed 32x11.50-15 BFG T/A KO on US Wheel 94 series 3" Lift - Rancho 9000x Rear No-Slip Locker Flowmaster 50 series SUV 2.25"
There is a very fine line between "hobby" and "mental illness." - Dave Barry
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: Gizzy42]
#822582
07/05/07 05:06 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 262
OP
Mudrunner
|
I just found Denso oxygen sensors online for $28. They don't come with the connectors, but I dont mind cutting and splicing my old ones.
Are Denso sensors any better than bosch?
Oxygen Sensor Brand: Denso
DENSO REPLACEMENT OXYGEN SENSOR, FRONT, LEFT -- Front Left UNIVERSAL Oxygen Sensor, 1 Required Per Vehicle, Reuse Your Old Connector, Electrical Installation Required, Non-Returnable, Sold Individually
1997 Isuzu Rodeo S 4WD
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: Tygger]
#822583
07/05/07 05:16 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 7,268
Isuzu Moderator
|
It is not the brand that is the big issue here. It is the cutting/splicing of the connector. Since the O2 sensor is a resistance sensor, things like splices, loose splices, corrosion at splices, different length wires, ect all affect what the ECU sees in the end.
Michael
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: mlclark]
#822584
07/05/07 06:27 PM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 262
OP
Mudrunner
|
Oh, I didnt know that... So are all O2 sensors basically the same except for the harness and fit? eg. if it fits in the hole, then its ok to use?
1997 Isuzu Rodeo S 4WD
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: Tygger]
#822585
07/05/07 08:58 PM
|
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 7,268
Isuzu Moderator
|
Weeeellll...I am not going to go as far as to say that. I would suspect that most O2 sensors are able to provide a reference voltage to the ECU and that range of reference is probably similar across most makes/models, but...I really don't know. Your ECU uses O2 sensors to adjust the a/f ratio and to check up on the function of your cats. If something is not right you might see low gas mileage, over heated cats or just a string of error codes.
What I am worried about is the discussion above is about 1-wire sensors, not the 3/4-wire heated sensors you need. I am actually surprised that you found generic heated sensors.
In the end, you can do whatever you want, but don't forget that if it does not work, you are going to be out an extra $100 for using the cheap sensors and you will still have to buy the correct ones.
Good Luck, Michael
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: Tygger]
#822586
07/06/07 12:02 AM
|
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 416
Mudrunner
|
Denso is a good brand, they are the only spark plugs I use and wouldnt have a problem with using their o2 sensors.
If you go with splicing in the old connectors I would suggest soldering the splices and covering with heat shrink tubing, you can get it at radio shack pretty cheap (remember to slide the tubing on the wire BEFORE soldering together). That would give you the best connection and least corrosion worries. Also make sure you dont get wires swapped around.
--Dave
1999 Rodeo LS 3.2 4x4 5 Speed 32x11.50-15 BFG T/A KO on US Wheel 94 series 3" Lift - Rancho 9000x Rear No-Slip Locker Flowmaster 50 series SUV 2.25"
There is a very fine line between "hobby" and "mental illness." - Dave Barry
|
|
Re: Generic O2 Sensor OK to Use???
[Re: Gizzy42]
#822587
07/06/07 06:31 AM
|
Joined: Jun 2003
Posts: 262
OP
Mudrunner
|
Thanks for the info. I'll prob. order the Denso ones, but does anyone know why there are multiple different Denso sensors for different locations? The Parts BinThese dont come with the connectors, but the prices are all different. NP2341000 $28.13 NP2342071 $58.96 NP2344206 $79.91 NP2344210 $61.36 NP2344212 $59.35 NP2344700 $69.60
Last edited by Tygger; 07/06/07 06:35 AM.
1997 Isuzu Rodeo S 4WD
|
|
|
|
|
|