Both those tires are loud on the road and the ride sucks. my suggestion is the wrangler with silent armor. they are rated very high by consumer reports,very quiet,good off road,smooth ride,and to top it off very resistant to punctures and cuts, heck they have kevlar in them thats why they are so good as far as ride,noise and dmg resistance. and they are a high milage rated tire. the downside is the expence, but you do get what you pay for.

cooper does make a semi aggressive tire called the discoverer atr. i never heard any complants from our customers on them and when they do wear out often the customer buys another set.

Bj cooper may be an off brand but that is one off brand i would buy,their tires always seem to last and handel well. personally i never had a set.,But when these wrangler gsa's wear out i am definatly debating between the atr cooper and the wrangler with silent armor