Hi-

I'd like to put a winch on my cherokee, and I've been looking at bumpers onto which I can mount one. It seems that there are two types available, a big one-piece bumper like a Warn, and a slimmer tube-type bumper like an OR FAB (just as examples - I'm not too concerned about brand at this point).

The big one-piece bumpers seem like they would provide good support for rigorous winching, stiffen up the unibody, and hold up well in an impact. However, they seem pretty bulky and heavy. The tube-type bumpers appear lighter and lower-profile, but look like they wouldn't hold up as well under a load or in an impact.

I know I'm supposed to evaluate my needs and do some research, but I've been looking for information and comparisons on the bb and elsewhere and haven't found anything comprehensive yet. Does anyone have any recommendations about which type would be better, or have any links to good information sources?

Thanks for any help!
Jon <img src="/forums/images/graemlins/cheers.gif" alt="" />