Nobody has mentioned the obvious (to me anyway) possibility of going to your local Pick-and-Pull yard. I replaced one of my headlights this way, paying only $35 for a good as new assembly. My local Pick-and-Pull usually has a couple Troopers.

You have a P-n-P there in Sacto.

1989 Trooper, 2.6
1989 Trooper, 2.8
1992 Ford F-350, 7.3

My Photos