Thanks Eddy,
My selection of taps is pretty minimal. I know they don't cost much, but I'm going to have trouble buying the belt, I don't want to spend anymore if I don't have to. I came up with a better ez out, so I'm headed outside to try again now.
I tried to find somebody with some better tools, but all I can come with is BIG tractor and semi truck tools.

As for the smoke, I didn't notice until I had shut the motor off. It was a steady wisp. All the hoses and lines seem good and don't appear to be leaking. I was mostly worried that the oil feed line was plugged, but it seems to be fine.