I buy everything from Spalding's , they're pretty close to me (They're in spokane, wa) but I've had them ship quite a few parts to me. Though they're technically a salvage yard they stock a lot of new body parts for toyotas, fenders, bumpers, lights, etc. Pretty reasonable at about $50 I think for an OEM fender, and in 8 years dealing with them I've never once had a problem.

86 4runner, pro comp AAL, Kayline Soft top, 31's but all stock